In case you were wondering, the Christmas holiday in Canada is very similar to Christmas in the U.S. Families get together. Some of those who attend also misbehave, thus ensuring story material for myriad future family get-togethers. (Not MY family, of course.) People exchange gifts, often in excess. People eat, ditto. At the end of the day, at least one someone, sometimes more than one, has a meltdown--too many noisy toys, too much candy, too many buns (American: rolls) with butter.
Again, not in MY family, of course. Except for the buns with butter. (Hello, I'm a woman. I have food issues. Also the same on both sides of the border. Get over it.) Which is what I thought of yesterday, in church.
Backing up: The United Church is a low-key kind of church, full of people who try earnestly and imperfectly to do the right thing in the world. Yesterday was a particularly low-key kind of Sunday. Our minister said he'd been thinking of a hard-hitting topic but decided instead to read a story at sermon-time. Fine.
But he also mentioned the hard-hitting topic, which was something along the lines of "What does Santa have that Jesus doesn't?"
So during the sermon, that's what I thought of instead of paying attention to what was actually happening around me. (That trait IS typical of my family, but that's another story.)
Some answers to the question are fairly obvious, not to mention sacreligious and actually not fair to Jesus. But here we go.
Santa's bag is full of toys, not guilt.
Santa's all about the "ho ho ho," while Jesus is about the "no no no!"
Santa's story ends with everybody getting presents; Jesus' story just starts at Christmas and goes on to include betrayal and death, which is hardly mitigated by resurrection and ascension (he's still GONE, after all).
But I was also thinking about the buns and the butter at the same time that I was pondering the Santa vs. Jesus debate. The thing about the buns and butter is that I haven't been eating much bread in the past year or so. It's not on my food plan. Mostly, I don't miss it. Seriously. I feel so much better physically (and wear clothing two sizes smaller, too) that it's totally worth allowing butter to be a special, planned event in my life. Which it was for Christmas. Which is all well and good.
And yet, I sat in church mentally focused on the last four buns and the stick of butter softening in its crystal dish. The food was at home in the kitchen, 20 miles away, but there in the choir loft, I could practically smell those buns, feel the squishy springy yeasty yum between my teeth, taste that salty fatty buttery...butter.
Well, okay, it may not sound as good as it felt yesterday. Still, here's the point: Those buns and the butter were as important to me in that moment as if they were the last buns in the world. As if no baker anywhere (or, say, Safeway) would ever make buns again. As if that one stick were the last butter on earth. As if I would be deprived of food--in fact, deprived of all things good--for the rest of my natural-born days.
None of which is true. There is plenty of food in my world, and I'm aware of and extremely grateful for that fact. My life is fabulous, overall. And yet, my brain includes wiring that fixates on these buns and butter. This part of my brain is not interested in logic; it's a reptile. It's interested in surviving the next famine. It doesn't care that it has never experienced famine in real life. Someone, somewhere in my ancestry must have. My brain stem remembers.
Which brings me back to Christmas. What if the excess of the holidays is part of that same reptilian wiring? What if we need the feeling of excess, of gluttony, of "TOO MUCH!" once a year, at the (literally) darkest time of the year? What if our inner reptile needs the excess to prepare for the future famine?
Especially in a year like this, when our future deprivation feels inevitable and won't be caused by any New Year's resolutions, but because the economic downturn has come in our own front doors.
Overall, I was pretty pleased with that thought. Yippee! Wiring is responsible! Too many toys, too much of a good thing, too many buns 'n' butter--all good!
But then came this thought: So what? So what if excess is inevitable? So what if we're biologically programmed--not just socially and culturally programmed--to over-do the end-of-year celebrations? Even if that's true, we don't get off the hook.
Because we can get around the wiring. We learned how in kindergarten. Civilization is all about learning to share, to protect and help each other, to balance our individual needs with the needs of the community, to postpone gratification in favo(u)r of a long-term goal.
In other words, civilization is the guilt, the "no no no!", the full story of Love (betrayal, sacrifice, death, resurrection, ascension) in all its messy, three-dimensional glory.
A scholar of religion might say that civilization is about Jesus, while the brain stem is about Santa. Or maybe not. Or in more precise language. But something like that.
To recap yesterday's sermon: Excess may be pre-programmed, but we can learn to short-circuit the wiring. Wanting the buns 'n' butter is a different thing from eating them. It is possible to celebrate holidays without credit-card-induced hangovers.
And here's today's status report: the buns are safely eaten by someone else. The butter is back in the fridge, right next to the Nanaimo bars. Oh man, Nanaimo bars are...hey...hmmm.

